 |
| Do conscientious people say I mean and I know more often? |
When we think of language we often think of neatly constructed sentences, but everyday casual conversation is peppered with hesitations, repetitions and sounds that you may not necessarily find in the dictionary. These linguistic phenomena often go unnoticed, with the exception, perhaps, of David Beckham TV interviews. Charlyn Laserna, Yi-Tai Seih and James Pennebaker’s research, however, was on features of this kind, They focused on uh and um (filled pauses) and also on words and phrases such as I mean, you know and like (discourse markers), calling both together ‘filler words’.
Although sometimes
thought of as superfluous or even careless, filler words may give clues about
the sort of person who utters them. The researchers investigated not only how
filler words were used across genders and age groups, but also whether they
correlate with certain personality traits.
They analysed transcriptions
of spoken conversations from 263 participants with ages ranging from 17 to 69. The
speech was recorded over 2-3 days using electronic devices programmed to
automatically take audio recordings at set time intervals, thus capturing
spontaneous natural speech.
The rate of use of each of the five filler
words (I mean, you know, like, um and uh) was analyzed in the conversations,
and because this study investigated these two types of filler words in relation
to one another, interesting comparisons could be made. People who were young,
female, or both young and female were more likely to use discourse markers.
This supports previous studies regarding the use of the discourse marker like. The rate of filled pauses was not
associated with gender; it was, however, associated with age, decreasing later
in life.
The researchers then became curious about the
way usage of these two types of filler words develops or changes over a
person’s lifetime. They divided participants into four age categories:
· early college (17-19)
· late college (20-22)
· early adulthood (23-34)
· and adulthood (35 and older)
They found that the increased use of discourse
markers among women only emerges during the early and late college years; as
people become older, the gender difference disappears. They explain that this may
be due to the way adolescents transition into adult roles. Graduating from college and entering a job
market or changing career may lead people to change the way they use filler
words.
The 252 participants had also completed
questionnaires regarding five personality traits - openness, conscientiousness,
extraversion, agreeableness, and neuroticism. The study found that an increased
use of discourse markers was associated with conscientiousness, while none of
the traits were related to the use of filled pauses.
The researchers explain that this may be
because conscientious people are generally more aware of themselves and their
surroundings, so when they converse with others, they use more discourse
markers, such as I mean and you know, to share their opinions or
rephrase them for their addressee.
Importantly, the findings indicate that filler
words could potentially provide a quick behavioral measure of speakers’ personality
traits. The researchers anticipate that one day people may use their
interpretation of these verbal cues to improve the quality of their communication
with others.
Um, like maybe…….
-----------------------------------
Laserna, Charlyn M., Yi-Tai Seih & James W. Pennebaker
(2014). Um . . . Who Like Says You Know: Filler Word Use as a Function
of Age, Gender, and Personality.Journal
of Language and Social Psychology, 33: 3, 328-338.
doi: 10.1177/0261927X14526993
This summary was written by Danniella Samos
